History and a Pitt vs. Penn State Rivalry

Dear Polo Fans:

The examination of a singular moment in Eastern water polo history—originally suggested by Scott Schulte and Mike Schofield—led to a deep dive (for me) about Puerto Rican involvement in NCAA men’s polo over the last four decades. This is perhaps not a new story—there have been waves of players from the island who have contributed significantly to the success of American collegiate teams—but the backstory of the Pitt program, which from 1975 – 78 was a top contender for Eastern honors, is particularly noteworthy due to Head Coach Miguel Rivera’s efforts of to engineer Panther success.

From what appeared to be a humble beginning—Bucknell’s 21-20 win over Pitt in what essentially was the Eastern final—emerged a far-more detailed story, one that reflects the many waves of Puerto Rican players coming to the mainland, specifically West Valley College in California and UMass in Massachusetts.

Really old guys at the pool
Sorry, they were not that old!

Following are the list of stories related to the central piece, which is about the November 13th, 1977 the Eastern Water Polo League (EWPL) Southern Division Championship match, where Bucknell rallied from two goals down with 18 seconds left to send the match into overtime:

The Game of a Lifetime: Bucknell 21, Pittsburgh 20, Sudden-Death Overtime in 1977 NCAA Qualifier

Scott Schulte, who played a major role in the match and ended up the NCAA all-time leading goal scorer, spoke w/Swimming World.

On The Record with Scott Schulte, Bucknell, CWPA and USA Water Polo Hall of Famer

Jorge Machicote, arguably the best player on the Pitt 1977 team, spoke with Swimming World about his journey from Puerto Rico to Pittsburgh and back.

Caps of Pitt
Pitt’s vintage caps.
Pitt Cathedral of Learning
Pitt’s Cathedral of Learning

Jorge Machicote, Puerto Rican and Pitt Water Polo Player: Not a Fighter But I Will Drown You in the Pool

Jay Fisette, the Bucknell co-captain who in 1977 scored the tying goal in regulation for Bucknell, then in 1978 coached Pitt against his former team, spoke with Total Water Polo.

Fisette Recounts Epic 1977 Bucknell-Pitt Championship Match

Miguel Rivera, the coach who built Pittsburgh into an instant winner due to an influx of talented players from Puerto Rico, spoke with Water Polo Plant.

Miguel Rivera and the Fantastic, Unbelievable and True Story of Pitt Water Polo and Puerto Rico

Willo Rodriguez, current head coach for the Puerto Rican national team, spoke with Swimming World about his past as a junior national team player and the sport’s future—both on the island and the mainland:

West Valley’s Willo Rodriguez on The Past, Present & Future of Puerto Rican Water Polo

Most importantly, Water Polo Planet has put up a message board topic about Puerto Rican water polo players in general and the 1977 game in particular. All are welcome to contribute their thoughts.

Pittsburgh Renegades Water Polo Club

Bucknell versus Pitt

There have been many folks who made time for interviews or assisted with background information on the games, the teams and the times. My thanks to them for their invaluable contribution to what has been an extremely rewarding endeavor. Following are some of the many people who helped make this project possible.

Chip Brenner; copy editor

James Smith; editor, Totalwaterpolo.com

Nikola Malezanov; publisher, Water Polo Planet; head coach, Washington & Jefferson men’s and women’s program

Jim Staresinic; publisher, Water Polo Planet; head coach, University of Pittsburgh women’s team

Craig Lord, Editor-in-Chief, Swimming World

Brent Rutemiller, Publisher, Swimming World, Executive Director, International Swimming Hall of Fame

Ed Haas; Director of Communications, Collegiate Water Polo Association

Paul Barren; former referee and high school water polo coach; CWPA Hall of Fame member

Jay Fisette; co-captain, 1977 Bucknell men’s team; head coach, 1978 Pitt Panthers

Barry Ford; member, 1977 Pitt Panther men’s team

Mark Gensheimer; member, 1977 Bucknell men’s team; CWPA Hall of Fame member

Mike Graff; head coach, Pittsburgh Renegades; board chair, USA Water Polo

Manfredo Lespier, former player, Puerto Rican national team; UC Irvine water polo

Jorge Machicote; member, Pitt Panther men’s team; former player, Puerto Rican national team

Rick Renner; co-captain, 1977 Bucknell men’s team

Miguel Rivera; former head coach, Pitt Panther men’s team; former player, Puerto Rican national team

Willo Rodriguez; current head coach, Puerto Rican men’s national team; head coach, West Valley College

Papo Ruiz; member, 1977 Pitt Panther men’s team

Mike Schofield; member, Pitt Panther men’s team; former coach, Navy men’s team, CWPA Hall of Fame member

Scott Schulte; member, 1977 Bucknell Bison men’s team; CWPA Hall of Fame member; USAWP Hall of Fame member

Mark Sickle; former Bucknell men’s team member (class of 1976)

Carlos Steffens; former player, Puerto Rican national team; three-time All-American at Cal-Berkeley

Luis Toro; member, Pitt Panther men’s team; former player, Puerto Rican national team

My heartfelt thanks to them all; this project has been deeply rewarding, particularly in a time when there’s so much sadness and frustration due to the coronavirus crisis.

If you enjoyed this piece / my work, please consider contributing to the following entities:

Swimming World—become one of the ISHOF’s “One in a Thousand” contributors

Total Water Polo—contribute to supporting free water polo content here

Water Polo Planetbuy a shirt to subsidize costs for one of the world’s most vibrant online polo forums



Alumni Game with Renegades at North Allegheny High School

Team photo with men and women and coach

With Thanksgiving break just around the corner, we have scheduled a date for our annual NA/Tiger Water Polo alumni game day:

Saturday, Nov. 30th

NA High School Pool

Warm Ups: 11 am

Game Time: 12 Noon

We invite alumni and masters players as well as current high school players – girls and boys. The more the merrier! It’s always a blast to bring everyone together for a reunion of sorts and a chance for some (who haven’t played in a while) to see if they still have what it takes! We look forward to seeing as many return players as possible for some water polo fun! If you’re a parent of a player, plan to watch the action. There’s no stress and the match ups are typically lively and quite fun to watch!

November news

4 women water polo players in holiday sweaters in Pittsburgh in front of Christmas tree


Thursday, 11/7: Chartiers Valley HS from 7:30-9pm with game prep with Michigan State.  This is not a full scrimmage with them.  If we have enough masters players we can scrimmage when they leave.

Main Line Division A League Dates:  1/26, 2/9, 2/23, 3/14 (Championship)

There will be two games played on each date. Schedule will be released as the other teams confirm.  Please respond if you think you can make any of these dates.

Save the Date for our Renegade Annual Fun Run!  Last year we had a lot of fun and even headed for Mexican and margaritas after.  Get your free tickets at the link below.  December 10th!  So far, Kinz, Pam, Jocelyn, and Joie have theirs!


If you are interested in purchasing an embroidered Pittsburgh Renegades towel for $20 before Christmas then please respond by Tuesday evening.  Your name can be placed on it at same cost.

Big weekend at Pitt as 16 teams come to Pittsburgh for the Men’s National Club Water Polo Championships on Friday, Saturday and Sunday, Nov 15-17, 2019.


Squads include: Lindenwood University of Missouri Valley Division, Boston College, Utah, University of Florida, University of Southern California, California State University Maritime Academy, United States Military Academy, University of California-San Diego, Oregon State University, University of Texas, United States Naval Academy, University of Notre Dame, University of Alabama, Michigan State University, and Pitt

Congrats to CMU Men’s team, https://collegiatewaterpolo.org/Club/#group that is ranked in D3 Club, tied for 7th in the nation.Extra swim time with Coach Mark is 8 to 11 am on Saturdays with the Saturday Swim School on the Northside at PPS Allegheny school. Call 412-298-3432 if the door is locked. Good for lifeguard candidates.Extra SKWIM game and water time with Coach Mark at Moon High School pool from 2-4 pm on Sunday, Nov 10, 17 and 24 and again Dec 8 and 22. $5 drop in fee. Kids and adults are welcome.If you want to be in the first wave of the lifeguard class, you need to wrap up the online lessons soon. Otherwise, we’ll be able to re-enroll for another course. Congrats to the few who have done so already. Coach Mark is helping to organize a regional Lifeguard Recruiting Initiative for aquatic leaders. Pass the word. See https://Guard.4Rs.org

New Month means New $5 Dues!!!

$5 dues can now be paid to Venmo as well  as Paypal

Venmo: Joie-Marhefka 

Paypal:  https://paypal.me/pools/c/852bhrrPqu

Wetskins tournament notes and team photo

Results from the first day’s games at the DC Wetskins: 

Renegades split. The first game was a loss to NOVA, 20 to 5. Pittsburgh scores the first three goals then down hill from there. Second game, a win against one of the four of the Wetskins teams, 10 to 8 in a close game. Up by 5 goals at mid game. Wetskins came back but Pittsburgh holds on.

Before day two.

The Renegades lost its fourth game to Rockville in DC. Closer battle than the score as the first quarter ended with an even point cout. Then Rockville pulled ahead. Renegades came back with three unanswered goals, but the final was Rockville, 14 to Renegades, 8.

Rockville moved on to the Championship Game.

The Lady Referee took the worst of the battle. No red cards though. Both sides were confused. Bittersweet depending on if you wanted to get home early or later.

BIG THANKS to the players from Cleveland and the Hawks and Miland for filling out the squad.